inside immigration information about marriage green cards and work visas in America
. . . home page
UPDATED JANUARY 2017
For many foreign nationals, while their American marriage green card is pending they are considered to be present in the USA legally as a “pending adjustee” or as an individual whose “adjustment of status (AOS) is pending. Another name for the status of someone whose permanent resident card is pending is “prucol.”
As an immigration attorney who specializes in marriage green cards, I am often asked about the status of a foreign national whose marriage green card is pending. If you’d like know more about the permanent resident card law, read further.
What is “PRUCOL” (Permanently Residing Under Color of Law)?
PRUCOL is a term that was established by American court judges to address situations in which the federal government has permitted the foreign national to remain in the U.S. but there is no category or name for the foreign national’s status.
These are commonly foreign nationals who:
What does “Permanently Residing in the USA under Color of Law” Mean?
Under the Immigration and Nationality Act and its implementing regulations, the USCIS determines the status of each alien in the United States. The term “color of law” is not clearly defined in the Immigration and Nationality Act. However, the USA Supreme Court Judges have confirmed that the USCIS has authority in alien matters. Therefore, when the USCIS is making a decision about a foreign national whose green card is pending, the USCIS is acting “under color of law.”
What is an Important Immigration Case Concerning “Color of Law?”
A case which illustrates this point is Holley v. Lavine. In Holley v. Lavine,* the USCIS sent a letter informing a Canadian citizen with six United States citizen children that she would not be deported at least until her children were grown.
This discretionary act by the USCIS was pursuant to its “color of law” authority.
For the USCIS to authorize a foreign national’s legal presence under “color of law,” the USCIS must (1) know of the alien’s presence;and, (2) must provide the alien with official assurance that enforcement of deportation is not planned.
In other words, applicants for adjustment of status to that of a lawful permanent resident card holder (marriage green card holder) are considered to be PRUCOL (allowed to remain in the USA) so long as their I-485 application is pending, no matter how long it takes. Their PRUCOL status ends if the I-485 application is denied or if the USCIS otherwise indicates that s/he is not permitted to remain in the USA and/or that his or her departure is being enforced.
What Documents Prove the USCIS Should Not Initiate Deportation of a Person While their Green Card is Pending?
In general, official USCIS receipts showing that the I-485 (application for marriage green card) and I-765 (application for work authorization) applications are pending suffice as official assurance that the permanent resident card is pending, and that enforcement of deportation is not planned and that the foreign national is in PRUCOL status.
*Holley v. Lavine, 553 F.2d 845 (2d Cir. 1977), cert. denied, 435 U.S. 947, 98 S. Ct. 1532, 55 L. Ed. 2d 545 (1978).